May 23, 2020

The Seven Bojjhaṅgas (Factors of Enlightenment)



by Sayagyi U Goenka

(from the Vipassana Research Institute Newsletter article. Adapted from the Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta course discourse)

There are seven bojjhaṅgas (factors of enlightenment) that have to be developed to reach the final goal of full liberation. They are:
1. sati (awareness);
2. dhamma-vicaya (investigation of Dhamma);
3. viriya (effort);
4. pīti (rapture);
5. passaddhi (tranquillity);
6. samādhi (concentration, absorption) and
7. upekkhā (equanimity).

The first bojjhaṅga is sati, awareness. Without it, further steps on the path cannot be taken. Sati, the objective observation of reality, is the most important factor because it must be continuously present from moment to moment with every other factor. For the Vipassana meditator, sati is the continuous awareness of the arising, passing bodily sensations (Sampajañña). Sampajañña becomes the sati (object of awareness).

Dhamma-vicaya is the second bojjhaṅga. The word caya or cayana means “to integrate.” Apparent, consolidated, integrated, illusionary truth creates delusion and confusion resulting in wrong decisions and actions. 

Vicaya or vicayana means to divide, dissect, disintegrate, separate (at the level of bodily sensations), which is what Vipassana intends you to do. 

To become a factor of enlightenment, dhamma-vicaya must become an experiential investigation— the direct experience of the phenomenon of arising and passing away of sensations. Pativedhana: piercing, penetrating Panna - dividing, dissecting, disintegrating, dissolving at the level of sensations, you reach the stage of total dissolution. You witness the solidified, material structure, the body, as actually nothing but subatomic particles, kalapas, arising and passing. 

Similarly, the mind and mental contents manifest as very solidified, intensified emotions - anger, fear, or passion - which overpower you. Vipassana, pativedhana, helps you. With pativedhana - the piercing, penetrating panna - you divide, dissect, disintegrate to the stage where this intense emotion is nothing but wavelets. The whole material and mental structures and the mental contents are nothing but wavelets, wavelets, anicca, anicca. 

Then the reality about this "I" or "mine" or "myself" becomes clear. They are just conventional words. There is no "I" to possess this mind-matter structure, this impermanent material and mental phenomena. Mere mind and matter constantly interact, constantly influence each other, and become a cause for the arising of each other, resulting in currents, cross-currents, and under-currents going on in what you call "I". 

Anatta (no "I") becomes clear at the experiential level.

The third bojjhaṅga is viriya (effort) as in sammā-vāyāmo in the Noble Eightfold Path. Great effort is required, but the effort is not to react, to let things just happen.  Even if you have been victorious in a thousand battles against a thousand warriors, this inner battle of non-reaction is more difficult because the old habit is to do something, to react. Some pressure is necessary to drill a hole in a precious gem, but too much pressure will break it. It is a middle path. Great effort or viriya is needed to keep the mind from wandering away, to be with the continuous awareness of arising, passing sensations (Sampajañña) - with equanimity.

As you keep practicing with sati, dhamma-vicaya, and viriya, the impurities go away, and you experience the fourth bojjhaṅga, pīti: rapture. You have to be careful. If you develop attachment to this free flow of pleasant vibrations throughout the body, if you look for it and cling to it, it is no longer a bojjhaṅga. If the understanding of anicca remains—that this is still the field of mind and matter, of arising and passing—then pīti becomes a factor of enlightenment.

After this, the meditator experiences passaddhi, the fifth bojjhaṅga: a state of deep tranquility and calmness. The mind becomes extremely peaceful, quiet, and tranquil. Again the meditator may have the false impression that this deep peace, never experienced before, is liberation. Just as pīti, can become a bondage if not used properly, in the same way, passaddhi can also become a bondage. You understand that it is only a midway rest-house: the final goal is still far away. You can check that the six sense doors are still functioning: open your eyes, or listen. You are still in the field of arising and passing. You have not transcended the field of mind and matter.

Thoroughly examine this passaddhi, this deep, tranquil, calm experience. Although difficult to grasp, a subtle oscillation remains, and this sensation is called adukkhaṃasukhaṃ (neither pleasant nor unpleasant). In pīti, the experience was pleasant; now it is just peaceful, and the danger is that anicca is not experienced. Detachment from craving towards pleasant sensation or aversion towards unpleasant sensation is much easier than detachment from this feeling of peace. You must be very attentive, with a very sharp mind, feel the subtle oscillation, check the six sense doors, and keep understanding that this experience is anicca. If you are aware of the very subtle oscillation, arising and passing, then it becomes a bojjhaṅga and gives you the strength to move further. Your experience grows.

There is often a question about adukkhaṃasukhaṃ or neutral sensations. The Buddha did not mean the initial, surface sensations which are neither pleasant nor unpleasant. That is totally different and causes craving and aversion because people get bored with it, lose interest, and want something else. Their experience has become stale. They want something more or new, something they don’t have. This is their old habit pattern.

The next enlightenment factor is samādhi—concentration or absorption. Sammā-samādhi takes us beyond all the planes of existence and results in full liberation from the bondage of birth and death, and from every type of suffering. It is practiced with sampajañña, the awareness of the mind-matter phenomenon and the realization of its nature of arising and passing of sensations within. With the practice of sammā-samādhi (with sampajañña), one after the other, the meditator attains the fruit of sotāpanna, sakadāgāmī, anāgāmī, and arahant. Thus, samādhi becomes an enlightenment factor.

Upekkhā—equanimity is the seventh factor of enlightenment. Like sati, it must be present from the beginning to the end, at every step. Whichever other factor is being developed, awareness and equanimity must always be present. 

When the bojjhaṅgas are practiced properly, they increase and become perfect; when each bojjhaṅga is perfect, enlightenment is perfect. This is the whole process of  Vipassana.

                                                                            ***


May 6, 2020

Correcting common misconceptions in the media about Vipassana


An article that appeared in 2017 on Vipassana (How Vipassana meditation breathes life into Anirban Lahiri's golf game), typifies the problem of non-meditators/inexperienced meditators writing Vipassana articles and books: errors and misconceptions creep in.

Their volition is good, but the few articles that appear in media are often from journalists yet to take a Vipassana course. Vipassana is unique, unlike anything else in this world because its ultimate goal is to take the practitioner beyond the realms of the six sense doors of this world, beyond the field of mind and matter. So very difficult, if not quite impossible, for yet-to-be-meditators to understand what is Vipassana, leave alone accurately write about it with their understanding of the mundane world.

It can be like writing an article about ice cream and taste of ice cream without ever having had an ice cream in life.

Which is why it is highly recommended that reporters, journalists, editors expressing professional interest in Vipassana are asked to first take a 10-day Vipassana course. Otherwise, tell them not to write anything about Vipassana. No information is better than wrong information. And Vipassana largely is shared worldwide by word of mouth.

Likewise, the above article in ESPN contained some common misconceptions:

1. 
"2,500-year-old Buddhist practice" 

Nothing "Buddhist" about Vipassana practice.

"During his lifetime, the Buddha did not convert a single person to Buddhism," writes the Principal Teacher of Vipassana Sayagyi U Goenka. "One may be surprised hearing this because we have been hearing, speaking, reading and writing contrary to this fact for such a long time. The mind is conditioned to believing this misconception. But the historical truth is that the Buddha neither taught 'Buddhism' nor converted anyone to being a 'Buddhist'.

"The Buddha taught Vipassana, the universal, non-sectarian practice to remove self-generated suffering - by removing deep-rooted defilements in the mind. The Vipassana Research Institute (VRI) CD contains the entire teaching of the Buddha and related literature in Pali language - 146 volumes with 52,602 pages and 7,448,248 words. Using technology to search through this vast literature, this fact is established: in the entire teaching of the Buddha, as well as in related commentaries, sub-commentaries, the word "Buddhist" has not been used with regard to his universal teachings, or to those who walked on the path he taught.

"Instead, the word used everywhere for the Buddha's teaching is "Dhamma", not "Buddhist Dhamma". Whenever any adjective precedes the word "Dhamma", it is qualitative, not sectarian. Like saddhamma (true Dhamma), ariyo dhammo (noble Dhamma), dhammo sanātano (eternal Dhamma), and so on. Those benefiting from practicing the Buddha's teaching have not been called Buddhists anywhere in the authentic texts, but these six words were used: dhammim, dhammiko, dhammattho, dhammacarim, dhammavihari, dhammanusari."

- Sayagyi U Goenka, The Buddha did not teach 'Buddhism'.

2.
Vipassana is not "breathing in and exhaling" as given in the ESPN article.

The writer meant Anapana, the preparatory exercise in a 10-day Vipassana course before Vipassana is taught on Day 4:

What is Anapana?

Anapana is a non-sectarian exercise to strengthen, concentrate the mind by using the natural respiration as the object of meditation.

The practitioner objectively observes the natural breath, as it comes in, goes out. No regulation of the breath. Anapana has nothing to do with breathing exercises that regulate the respiration.

More information: Anapana

Register here to learn Anapana (until Vipassana courses resume worldwide, after the Covid-19 lockdown): a live (free) Anapana tutorial session on Webex 

Anapana for children


3. 
"Before his death in 2013, Goenka launched 200 centers across the globe."

No, he did not launch 200 centres (the number is 206 now, and 145 gipsy camp locations)

* New Vipassana centres are established with local Vipassana students deciding it would be beneficial to have a Vipassana centre in their area. Then they get in touch with an existing Vipassana centre and are informed of guidelines for establishing a new Vipassana centre, how to form a not-for-profit registered trust etc.

* Then local students search for suitable land in the area for a Vipassana centre, get it approved by the Vipassana teacher for the area, and then buy the land through voluntary donations from existing students.

 * They set about establishing the new centre in accordance with a template followed worldwide.

* Sayagyi U Goenka's involvement in the new centres was often limited to giving it a Pali name, starting with the word 'Dhamma' - such as Dhamma Thali in Jaipur, Rajasthan, India.

* Trustees are appointed on an annual basis on voluntary work to manage the centre, under the guidance of a Vipassana teacher.

* Accounts of the Vipassana centre are audited annually by a reputed chartered accountant firm.

* Sayagyi U Goenka (1924 - 2013) was directly involved in establishing the main centre
Dhamma Giri (in Igatpuri, 150 km from Bombay) but as far as is known he did not instruct anyone,"Okay, you better start a new centre" here or there.

* He has instructed that there should never be any advertisement for Vipassana.  Word of mouth is sufficient.

4.
"There is no set fee for the 10-day course, but students usually make donations -- anything from $10 to $10,000"

There is no fee - set or otherwise.

Nobody goes around asking any student for a donation at the end of a Vipassana course. A donation table is kept in a corner on Day 10 - when the rule of silence breaks, and whoever wants can go and give a donation according to volition and means.

What are the charges/fee for a Vipassana course?

Mr S. N. Goenka: Charges?! Dhamma is priceless! There is no fee and there can never be a fee charged for teaching Vipassana. Vipassana courses are completely free of charge. Earlier, for a short time, some small actuals were charged for boarding and lodging expenses. Fortunately, that has been removed. So one does not have to pay anything to attend a Vipassana course.

What are the reasons for no fees being charged for doing a Vipassana course?

SNG: One reason, as I said, is that Dhamma is priceless. It cannot be valued in money. Another reason is that a student taking a Vipassana course practices renunciation from the householders' responsibilities, for the duration of the course. He or she lives like a monk or a nun, on the charity of others. This is to reduce the ego, a big cause of one's misery. If one even pays a small token fee, then the ego gets built up, and one may say, "Oh, I want this. This facility is not to my liking", "I can do whatever I want here", and so on. This ego becomes a big hindrance in progressing on the path of Dhamma. This is another reason why no fee is charged. This has been the Dhamma tradition for millennia. The Buddha did not charge any fee for distributing this invaluable gem of Vipassana!

How are expenses met for a Vipassana course, since no fee is charged from students?

SNG: The expenses are met from voluntary donations (dana) from students who have completed at least one Vipassana course. The donation, in money and voluntary services, is given with the Dhamma volition that, "As I benefited by getting this wonderful technique due to the generous dana of others, may others also benefit ". Most important is the volition with which the dana is given. Even a handful of fertile soil given with a pure Dhamma volition, is far more beneficial than a bag of gold given with ego, or with no Dhamma volition. The dana given with a pure mind gives benefits to the giver.   However, this does not mean that somebody will go around at the end of the course, asking every student if he wants to give a donation. A table is put in a quiet corner, and whoever wishes to give dana goes there and gives it, that's all.

---

No fees are paid to Vipassana teachers. All teachers are required to have an independent means of livelihood, source of income to support their Vipassana service. "Never make Vipassana a business/livelihood " - Sayagyi U Goenka.

---

5.
"Miller explained that everything a person does at the physical level is affected by the health of his mind, and everything a person does at the mental level is affected by the health of his body. Focusing energy on one point -- breathing -- neutralizes the fight between the physical and mental being. Lahiri is drawn to this, Miller said, because a golfer uses the same technique on the course."  

Not quite. Obviously what had been explained to the ESPN reporter flew over the head. Encourage reporters, journalists, editors to take a 10-day Vipassana course, if they wish to report about it. At least request them to look up the Vipassana website. They can least copy-paste accurate information from the Vipassana website, we have no objection.

Mind and body are interlinked. And the uniqueness of Vipassana is that it allows us to explore this mind-body phenomenon called 'I' as a holistic entity - at the level of mind-body interaction. This interaction happens at the level of bodily sensations that a Vipassana practitioner is trained to become aware of  - with equanimity.

Bodily sensations are not new. What is new is our Vipassana-enabled faculty to be aware of them.

Sensations arise and pass away every moment in our life - from the moment we are born to the moment we die.  Vipassana opens up this faculty of awareness of sensations - just as opening the eyes give sight.

Vipassana is insight.

Earlier we gave all attention to the outside world. Now for the first time, we give all attention to the inner world.

The real cause of suffering is within. The way out of suffering is within. Happiness is within.

The deepest part of the mind is 24/7 connected to our bodily sensations (biochemical flow), not to anything in the outside world.  For instance, even in deep sleep we rub a mosquito bite or get up to go to the loo. So by working at the level of sensations, we work at the deepest root-level of the mind where habit patterns are formed.

Earlier we blindly reacted to these sensations with craving or aversion. Deep-rooted habit patterns are formed of reaction to particular external situations. Vipassana gradually breaks that habit pattern. How? By training the mind to observe - with equanimity - any sensations that arise with sensory experience (including thoughts) instead of blind reaction. Just observe, as a scientist objectively observes a lab phenomenon.

Every sensation becomes a tool to develop equanimity.

Equanimity is purity.

Sensations mean any physical feeling, from gross sensations such as pain, itching to subtler sensations such as tingling, a flow of undercurrent. As the mind progressively becomes sharper and purer, it feels subtler and subtler sensations. Sensations are the biochemical flow of subatomic particles arising and passing from mind-body interaction.

We observe laws of the universe, the truth of the cosmos, at the level of sensations. The basic law of nature: impermanence. Everything changes, every moment.

The laws of nature are the same inside, outside. The subtlest law of nature is so subtle that it can be experienced only within - experienced, not described.

 Vipassana can be called Quantum Physics in practice.

Since the above article was about a sports person, here is a cricket analogy: Vipassana is the entire focus on this delivery of this over, nothing else in the mind. The previous ball that got the batsman beaten or a dropped catch is left aside, no fear of the future of getting out. Just entire attention on this ball. What former Indian cricket captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni often said "being in the present moment."

Anyone being equanimous (very balanced mind) is to an extent observing equanimity at the level of sensations, knowingly or unknowingly.

Likewise, Jesus Christ whom Sayagyi U Goenka called "Prince among Saints" in the evening discourses during a 10-day Vipassana course. Jesus generated compassion and forgiveness for the Roman soldiers who were even then torturing him to death. Such compassion was born of superhuman equanimity to sensations when having iron nails hammered into his hands and feet to a wooden cross.

By whatever name or no name, Vipassana is Awareness of bodily sensations with Equanimity - moment to moment.

Vipassana is about being with the reality of the present moment, at the level of impermanent bodily sensations passing away as they arise. Wisdom comes naturally into play.

Vipassana is of infinite benefits for all, in the golf course or cricket field of life.