May 13, 2018

Why the Buddha was not a 'Buddhist'



An unique article by Principal Teacher of Vipassana Sayagyi U Goenka (1924-2013) explaining this most unfortunate misconception that has kept millions away from experiencing the self-dependent, universal path of Vipassana  - to directly experience truth of who we really are, and what is our real work in life. 


"That Vipassana is being practiced by people of all religions, in so many countries worldwide, proves that the original teaching of the Buddha is not meant to be confined to any particular religion. It is universal. People of all religions (including religious leaders), all races, castes and communities of the world are benefiting from it. With practice of Vipassana, violence, aversion and ill-will between different religions and communities will end.  "

The Buddha did not teach Buddhism. During his lifetime, he did not convert a single person to Buddhism. One may be surprised hearing this because we have been hearing, speaking, reading and writing contrary to this fact for such a long time. The mind is conditioned to believing this misconception. But the historical truth is that the Buddha neither taught 'Buddhism' nor converted anyone to being a 'Buddhist'.

The Buddha taught Vipassana, the universal, non-sectarian practice to remove self-generated suffering - by removing deep-rooted defilements in the mind. The Vipassana Research Institute (VRI) CD contains the entire teaching of the Buddha and related literature in Pali language - 146 volumes with 52,602 pages and 7,448,248 words. Using technology to search through this vast literature, this fact is established: in the entire teaching of the Buddha, as well as in related commentaries, sub-commentaries, the word "Buddhist" has not been used with regard to his universal teachings, or to those who walked on the path he taught.

Instead, the word used everywhere for the Buddha's teaching is "Dhamma", not "Buddhist Dhamma". Whenever any adjective precedes the word "Dhamma", it is qualitative, not sectarian. Like saddhamma (true Dhamma), ariyo dhammo (noble Dhamma), dhammo sanātano (eternal Dhamma), and so on. Those benefiting from practicing the Buddha's teaching have not been called Buddhists anywhere in the authentic texts, but these six words were used: dhammim, dhammiko, dhammattho, dhammacarim, dhammavihari, dhammanusari.

Not only during the lifetime of the Buddha but even in the next few centuries, we do not come across words like "Buddhist" or "Buddhism" anywhere. About 250 years after the Buddha, Emperor Ashoka, once an ambitious bloodthirsty war monger, came in contact with the true teaching of the Buddha (*1). He benefited from Dhamma and inspired others to walk on the path of Dhamma, and was therefore called "Dhamma Ashoka", not "Buddhist Ashoka".

Out of compassionate affection for his subjects, Emperor Ashoka encouraged the practice of Dhamma, not Buddhism. He did not send 'Buddhism' but the Dhamma ratana (the jewel of Dhamma),  to neighhbouring countries and to distant western countries as well, as a priceless gift from India. His envoys were called  Dhammadūtas (messengers of Dhamma), not "messengers of Buddhism". None of the edicts on rocks and columns of Emperor Ashoka that have come to light so far contain the word "Buddhist"; everywhere, the word "Dhamma" is used. Dhamma is universal, applicable for everyone.

Therefore  Emperor Ashoka, who walked on this path, exhorted  that people of one sect should never criticize or condemn another sect; there should be respect and goodwill for fellow beings. This is the distinguishing feature of the universal Dhamma - experienced with practice of Vipassana.

                Dhamma Pattana Vipassana Centre, Global Vipassana Pagoda, Mumbai India

How and when this universal teaching of the Buddha became confined within narrow sectarian limits, is a subject for investigation. It is a research topic for linguistic and historical scholars to discover when and by whom these sectarian words like "Buddhist", "Buddhism" and "Buddhist philosophy" came into use. VRI will also conduct relevant research in this area.

One may rightly surmise that words like 'Buddhism' and 'Buddhist' may have come into use after India forgot the essence of the true practical teaching of the Buddha. Gradually this country also lost the entire original related literature and, worst of all, it lost Vipassana, the practical quintessence of the Buddha's teaching. This is the beneficial practice that breaks all artificial barriers of caste, race, class and religion. Vipassana is direct experiential proof that the Buddha's teaching is universal. When Vipassana was lost, the original teaching of the Buddha was lost, a very big loss not only for India but also for humanity.

The practical-oriented teaching of the Buddha became "Buddhism" and became limited to those people who called themselves "Buddhists". Because of the loss of Vipassana, most people forgot the universal and practical nature of the Buddha's teaching that is applicable to all. As long as it was "Dhamma" or 'Vipassana', people did not hesitate to practice it but as soon as it began to be called "Buddhism", the delusion naturally spread: "This is for Buddhists, not for us". That which the Buddha called appamano dhammo, (universal laws of nature) became confined by the narrow bounds of an organized religion, became pamanavatti (limited) and unfortunately was placed in the shallow row of the different religions of the world. Because of this, people remained ignorant of its universally beneficial nature, and were deprived of the benefits obtained from it.

Fortunately  a few wise people in the neighbouring country of Myanmar preserved this universal technique of Vipassana in its pure form for centuries, from generation to generation. With infinite gratitude to them, Vipassana has returned to India, and is being shared again around the world.

That Vipassana is being practiced by people of all religions, in so many countries worldwide, proves that the original teaching of the Buddha is not meant to be confined to any particular religion. It is universal. People of all religions (including religious leaders), all races, castes and communities of the world are benefiting from it. With practice of Vipassana, violence, aversion and ill-will between different religions and communities will end.

Vipassana is a very ancient meditation technique of India. Any person who becomes a Buddha attains enlightenment by rediscovering this lost technique. In the ancient Vedic literature of India before the lifetime of the Buddha, there is abundant praise for this technique. But it is only praise. India of that time, during the lifetime of Siddhhata Gotama, had completely forgotten the practical application of this technique. The prince turned ascetic Gotama rediscovered this technique by exerting much effort. Out of compassion, he shared the path for benefit of all. Unfortunately after a few centuries, India forgot this historical Buddha and once again lost the ancient practice of Vipassana - the very practice that led to the country being very prosperous and being recognized as a vishwa-guru (teacher of the world). Fortunately, practice of Vipassana is again reviving in India, and worldwide.

Gotama Buddha was neither a god, nor an incarnation of any god, nor a prophet of any god. He did not become the Buddha because of divine grace. By perfecting his paramitās (wholesome mental qualities that help to dissolve egoism, and leading to total purification of the mind), by exerting strenuous efforts and strong determination he attained full enlightenment. He was therefore called a sammāsambuddha (one who becomes fully enlightened by his own efforts). He was not a mythological being but a historical person.

A sammāsambuddha is the highest state that can be attained by any being. With infinite compassion, Sammāsambuddha Gotama taught Vipassana all his life. Because he discovered and taught the operation of the natural laws of kamma (law of cause and effect), he was called a supreme theist. In those days in India, this was the only acceptable definition of theism.

If the true nature of the historical Buddha comes to light, misconceptions about the Buddha will be removed. The importance of individual right effort to free oneself from suffering will replace blind beliefs, or blind dependence on some divine power.

Many historical incidents occurred during the long lifetime of Buddha to prove that he did not establish any religious sect. He never had any intention of converting anyone and confining them within the bounds of an organized religious sect. With infinite compassion he taught the pure universal Dhamma with only one objective: "bahujana hitāya, bahujana sukhāya" (for the good of many, for the happiness of many) and not for the good of any particular religion or sect.

The Buddha made successful efforts to stop cruel rituals like animal sacrifice. He uprooted the caste system by enabling people to realize that it is not birth but one's actions that define nobility. People stopped wasting time in rituals and blind beliefs, and started practicing Vipassana to purify their minds and live a life of sīla (wholesome life), samādhi (mastery of the mind) and paññā (wisdom).

Merely rote learning and reciting of any scriptures may offer some calm at surface level of the mind, but cannot remove deep-rooted negative habit patterns that cause suffering. The mind surgery of Vipassana is needed to free oneself from negativities, and to directly experience the law of cause and effect: our actions sow the seeds of our happiness or suffering.

Notes:

*1) " Furious at its resistance to him, Asoka attacked Kalinga and subjugated it in a bloody war. Then, after the fighting was over, he saw how many innocent people had been killed and how terrible was the suffering of this once-prosperous land. Heartsick at his own actions, he resolved to abjure the sword.

"It was at this time that Asoka came to know about the teachings of the Buddha and was instantly attracted. He began by studying the words of the Enlightened One. Then someone told him that knowledge of the texts was not enough to give an understanding of the real meaning of the teachings; that can come only through the development of insight, that is, Vipassanā-bhāvanā, or Vipassana meditation.

"The best place then to learn Vipassana was at Bairath in the state of Rajasthan, where a monk named Upagupta taught. Handing over power to his subordinates, Asoka set out for Rajasthan. After 300 days he returned to his capital, a changed man. Now his volition was to share the teachings of the Buddha throughout his empire; he had been inspired by ehi passiko, the wholesome wish that others may come and see the Dhamma." - 'The Emperor Asoka and Sayagyi U Ba Khin', Vipassana Research Institute, Aug 13, 2011.
---
From the original article 'Why the Grand Vipassana Pagoda?' , Vipassana Research Institute, October, 1997. The Global Pagoda in Mumbai is to: a) enable thousands of Vipassana students to meditate together, in the world's largest stone dome without any supporting pillars; b) to remove misinformation that has kept millions away from experiencing a self-dependent, universal path - to directly experience truth of who we really are, and what is our real work in life.

The practice of Vipassana the Buddha shared is the highest practical science, a direct realization of the subtlest truths of nature -  to gain equanimity and wisdom to more effectively deal with problems of day to day life, and experience what is real happiness. This can be experienced by anyone willing to give a fair trial and invest ten days of time - to change a lifetime. Vipassana courses are offered worldwide free of cost.

Feb 21, 2018

Benefits of dana with right volition


by Sayagyi U Goenka

Dāna (donation) when given with pure volition, is highly beneficial. When one unselfishly and humbly gives dāna with Dhamma volition for the benefit of all beings, one’s mind is free from greed, harshness, enmity, selfishness, miserliness, and dullness. One's mind becomes noble, gentle, tender, tranquil, generous, virtuous and alert.

To give dāna is the fundamental duty of householders.

In the ancient spiritual tradition of India, dāna has always had special importance.

In ancient times, virtuous and wealthy householders and sages used to organise great ceremonies of dāna.

Noble donors like Emperor Vessantara in ancient times and Emperor Harsha established the illustrious ideal of donating all their possessions. Their volition behind giving dāna was truly selfless.

The wealth of the community tends to accumulate with the rulers and wealthy men. If this wealth remains with them, it begins to rot and makes the whole community unhealthy. If wealth is re-distributed, its purity is maintained.

Having understood this, a wise donor, considered his wealth as the wealth of the community. To save himself from the improper hoarding of wealth, he gave dāna so that others could share and enjoy this wealth.

This wise policy of equitable distribution of wealth preserved the equilibrium of social prosperity and prevented it from becoming an unbalanced destructive force.

The wealthy donor distributed his wealth equitably from time to time. He did not give his wealth with the desire to obtain something in return nor to boost his ego.

“Viceyya dānaṃ dātabbaṃ,

yattha dinnaṃ mahapphalaṃ.”


Dāna given with wisdom is highly beneficial.

There are two kinds of dāna:

1. Vaṭṭamūlaka dāna: the dāna that keeps one entangled in the cycle of existence(bhavacakka).

2. Vivaṭṭamūlaka dāna: meaning the dāna that takes one out of the cycle of existence.

A wise person gives dāna such that it frees him from the cycle of existence.

As with all other kamma, so too the kamma of dāna is good or bad according to the volition of one’s mind. The vivaṭṭamūlakamind that cuts the cycle of existence is free of craving, free of aversion, and free of ignorance. Only the dāna given with this kind of mind is called vivaṭṭamūlaka dāna, which destroys the cycle of existence.

While giving such dāna, we do not consider our own benefit. Instead, we are delighted to see the happiness and welfare of the person receiving our dāna. When we take delight in the happiness of others, our minds become pure and tender and is freed from the limitations of narrow self-interest.

However, if while giving dāna we wish for any personal benefit, our mind is stained with craving, vaṭṭamūlaka. Dāna given with such volition of mind will only prolong the cycle of existence. If, as a result of giving dāna, we wish for worldly happiness, fame, respect, profit, or rebirth in heaven—our minds remains in bondage instead of becoming free from bondage.

Therefore, giving dāna with a mind stained with craving is wrong but even worse is to give dāna with the mind defiled with aversion. That becomes a cause of even greater harm to us; it becomes a process of earning demerits in the name of Dhamma. Not only do we lose the donated wealth, but simultaneously, the kamma done with a defiled mind becomes the cause of great sorrow and misfortune.

Let us understand by examples how we give dāna with the mind defiled with aversion:

A beggar standing outside my door is calling out, “Sir! Give alms, sir! Give alms!” Becoming enraged at his repeated pleas, I throw a coin at him to get rid of him. At that time, my mind is filled with anger and irritation.

Some people collecting donations for some school, or hospital have come to my shop. As soon as I see them, I fly into a rage and start grumbling, “Donation, donation! All the time, people are asking for donations! Accountant, give them five rupees and get rid of them.” While giving them the money, my mind is filled with resentment towards these undesirable donation-seekers.

Some minister or political leader orders me to give a donation for some cause. I do not have the slightest interest in it but I am afraid to refuse so I give dāna out of fear.

My Dhamma-teacher (kalyāna mitta) has sent a message to give a donation for some project. I do not wish to give this dāna but do so out of deference and diffidence.

The rest of the people in my community have given dāna for some work. I do not have the slightest desire to give any dāna  for it. However, if I do not donate, others will criticize me. So I give dāna to protect my reputation.

My rival has become famous because he has given a large donation. I give a bigger donation than him out of egotism.

In this way, I give dāna with the unwholesome volition of anger, resentment, irritation, fear, deference, diffidence, rivalry, jealousy, hostility, pride, and conceit. And after giving such dāna, I regret it whenever I remember it and defile my mind.

All actions done with wholesome Dhamma-volition are beneficial; all actions done with unwholesome volition are non-beneficial. For all benefits of Dhamma, dāna should always be given with wholesome volition.

When dāna is given with wholesome volition, the mind is filled with a feeling of renunciation and with delight at the happiness and benefit of others. It is filled with contentment before giving dāna, while giving dāna and after giving dāna.

Before giving dāna, such joyful thoughts arise in the mind, “I shall give dāna. Others will benefit from my dāna and gain happiness.”

While giving dāna also, my mind is suffused with these joyful thoughts, “I am giving dāna. I am fulfilling the duty of a householder! By this dāna, the recipients will benefit and gain happiness.”

After giving dāna, my mind is repeatedly filled with these auspicious thoughts, “I have given the dāna of food or clothes or medicines so that the recipients will be healthy and strong in mind and body and practising sīla, samādhi, and paññā, will attain their own welfare and will become the cause of the welfare of many. I have given the dāna of this cottage staying in which the meditator will practise sīla, samādhi and paññā. By practising Anapana and Vipassana, he will experience the peace and happiness of nibbāna and will become the cause of the peace and happiness of many.”

Whether the recipient of my dāna is a fully liberated arahant or any virtuous saintly person who is a follower of the path of arahants, my mind will be filled with boundless joy, “It is my good fortune that, by my dāna, such a saintly person will remain healthy and strong for some time, and through him, many others will gain happiness! By accepting my dāna he has bestowed boundless compassion on me.”

Pubbeva dānā sumano, dadaṃ cittaṃ pasādaye;

datvā attamano hoti, esā yaññassa sampadā.

(AN 2.6.37, Chaḷaṅgadānasuttaṃ)


The donor is happy before giving dāna, while giving dāna, and after giving dāna. Such is the abundance of happiness of dāna offered with wholesome volition.

In this way before giving dāna, while giving dāna, as well as after giving dāna, the donor fills his mind with pure contentment.


May all beings be happy, be fully liberated from all suffering.

( original article: Right Volition of Dāna, Vipassana Newsletter, December 2009)

*****

One loses nothing by giving dāna with right volition - at the apparent level, it seems one's money is becoming less, but even this money is not actually lost. Even at the mundane level, one loses nothing. Dhamma takes care.

- Sayagyi U Goenka, one-day course discourse.

****
The Global Vipassana Pagoda was built and is being maintained with selfless Dhamma service and very meritorious voluntary donations from people worldwide, for the benefit and happiness of many. 

An organization wished to contribute the entire costs of building the Global Vipassana Pagoda - but the offer was respectfully declined because Sayagyi U Goenka most compassionately wished that many people earn the immeasurable benefits of donation for such a unique, most beneficial Dhamma project. 

Whether donating thousands of dollars or the elderly lady giving a few coins, the benefits are proportionate to the purity of volition when giving the donation.
****
Opportunity to earn most beneficial merits (and to share those merits with all beings)